Godric LogoGodric |  Blog
← Back to all articles
Hiring is a Craft

The Signal Gap: Why Hiring is, and will continue to be, a Craft.

By Anders Lundholm
RecruitmentTalent AcquisitionPeople StrategyPeople AnalyticsAI AugmentationTalent DensityHiring ScienceCandidate ExperienceInterview StrategyRecruitment OperationsStructured Interviewing


There is a kind of "new car smell" in People Operations at the moment. It’s the feeling of finally migrating your team over to a modern ATS (something like an Ashby or a Gem). The dashboards are clean, the scheduling is automated, and for a moment, it feels like the hiring problem is solved.

But then the "Hypercare" period ends and reality sets in.

You realize that while you’ve built a faster, sleeker pipeline, the signal flowing through it remains fuzzy. You are still drowning in a sea of 400+ applications per role. You are still meeting candidates who sound suspiciously like an LLM in their interviews. More importantly, your hiring managers, in charge of ‘sticking the landing’, are still giving you feedback that boils down to a "vibe" rather than a data point.

Your ATS handles the hard wiring; your people generate the signal. We call this the Craft of Hiring. It bridges the gap between the art of human connection and intuition and the rigor of data science, turning noise into high-value insight.

Closing the Post-Hire Data Gap
We recently spoke with a Head of People Ops at a fast-scaling tech firm. They had just moved mountains to integrate their HRIS and ATS, aiming for the "holy grail" of people analytics. They wanted to see if an employee’s interview performance actually predicted their success six months in.

The problem? The dirty nature, or complete absence of, data.

The "interview notes" were filled with phrases like "Good energy" or "strong culture fit." You can’t scale and retain accuracy on individual "vibe." To get the kind of analytics that actually drive a business forward, you need structured, high-science inputs throughout a hiring cycle. 



AI-Augmentation: An Instrument, Not a Replacement

We have to talk about the elephant in the room: candidates are getting better at appearing great. Between AI-optimized resumes and real-time interview assists, "noise" is at an all-time high.

Finding the "gems" in this environment requires a new kind of methodology. We see AI-augmentation as an exoskeleton for the interviewer. Instead of replacing the human, Godric sharpens them. It provides the structured frameworks that force an interviewer to dig deeper, to spot inconsistencies, and to capture the kind of evidence that stands up in a debrief.

When you give a Hiring Manager an AI-augmented plan and note-taking, you aren't just giving them a list of questions; you’re giving them a sharper eye for talent.


Democratizing the Craft

Hiring excellence shouldn't live in a silo. Too often, there is a massive drop-off in quality between the TA’s initial screen and the Hiring Manager’s final interview, leading to a poor candidate experience in an inefficient hiring process.

Democratizing the "Craft of Hiring" means ensuring that everyone who touches a candidate is working from the same high-signal playbook.

  • For the Recruiter: It’s about moving from administrative coordinator to a Strategic Partner who provides the HM with deep, structured insights before they even walk into the room.
  • For the Hiring Manager: It’s about having a "Recruitment Assistant" that handles the mundane task of note-taking so they can focus 100% on the human across from them.


The Bridge Between HR and the Business

At Godric, we believe the most important work happens in those 45 minutes when two people are talking.

Our mission is to bridge the gap between HR efficiency and Hiring Manager quality. We turn the unstructured "black box" of an interview into a structured data stream. 

Because at the end of the day, a company isn't a collection of software licenses. It’s a collection of people. And the craft of finding those people is far too important to be left to chance.




Are you building a pipeline of candidates, or a database of signals?
See how Godric democratizes Hiring Science across your Recruitment Cycle.